The more I read that statement of yours, the more ridiculous it sounds.
If either scheme had any “theological merit,” it would’ve been discovered, preached, and taught by the saints through the ages.
Instead, you would have us believe God’s people knew nothing about the proper interpretation of the Apocalypse until two Jesuit priests published their Futurist and Preterist commentaries 1500 years later, to counter the interpretations of the Protestant Reformers.