How low will the left go?

[Guest shiloh357]

Why should Israel have to give up land it won from Jordan and Egypt when it was invaded by them?

Stop being a sore loser Amor. You guys lost, Israel won, it rightfully belongs to them now.

And yes, she did meet with Michael Moore. She was highlighted on his website before the media ever talked to her.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Fine in that case fully annex the West Bank and Gaza, and grant full citizenship rights,including the right to vote to all those who live there. Do you see that as a solution? If you don't, what future do you see for those living in the territories that Israel "won"?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

They don't deserve Israeli citizenship. It was not Israel's fault that the Palestinians are in the West Bank and Gaza. It is the Arab countries that created refugee crisis. They should repatriate their bretheren in Arab lands. It is the least they can do for making them refugees in the first place. That would be the ideal solution. But I guess expecting them to care about their own is asking a too much of them.

The Arabs kicked some 600,000 Jews out of Arab countries in 1948. The Jews had the moral fortitude to take their own people into Israel and give them a home, and it wasn't even their fault that those Jews became refugees. The Arabs CREATED their refugee problem and want to lay it someone else's doorstep. The world is always having to clean up after them. They need to take rsponsibility for their own mess.

[amor]

Why should Israel have to give up land it won from Jordan and Egypt when it was invaded by them?

Stop being a sore loser Amor. You guys lost, Israel won, it rightfully belongs to them now.

And yes, she did meet with Michael Moore. She was highlighted on his website before the media ever talked to her.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Fine in that case fully annex the West Bank and Gaza, and grant full citizenship rights,including the right to vote to all those who live there. Do you see that as a solution? If you don't, what future do you see for those living in the territories that Israel "won"?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

And you don't think the UN and Arab nations wouldn't have a fit over that? Israel has wanted to annex but the UN is completely against the idea of Israel being there in the first place. You're living in a utopia Armor. Israel annexing it and granting citizenship rights, while best for both sides, would not be allowed by Hamas, PLO, the UN (all three Terrorist organizations), the Arab governments, or the anti-semetic European goverments (Germ-ance...you figure out what that's a combo of).

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I don't think that too many of the above would be too concerned, because of the demographic realities of such a situation. Israel already has a population that is 20% Arab adding the combined Arab populations of Gaza and the West Bank would bring that much nearer to 50% given that the Arab population of both Israel and the occupied territories is increasing at a greater rate than the Jewish one, this would lead to a democraticstate with a Palestinian Arab majority within a very short period. That is why such a policy would be a no-no to any Israeli government; and why if you believe in democracy a two state solution is the only viable one.

[amor]

Why should Israel have to give up land it won from Jordan and Egypt when it was invaded by them?

Stop being a sore loser Amor. You guys lost, Israel won, it rightfully belongs to them now.

And yes, she did meet with Michael Moore. She was highlighted on his website before the media ever talked to her.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Fine in that case fully annex the West Bank and Gaza, and grant full citizenship rights,including the right to vote to all those who live there. Do you see that as a solution? If you don't, what future do you see for those living in the territories that Israel "won"?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

They don't deserve Israeli citizenship. It was not Israel's fault that the Palestinians are in the West Bank and Gaza. It is the Arab countries that created refugee crisis. They should repatriate their bretheren in Arab lands. It is the least they can do for making them refugees in the first place. That would be the ideal solution. But I guess expecting them to care about their own is asking a too much of them.

The Arabs kicked some 600,000 Jews out of Arab countries in 1948. The Jews had the moral fortitude to take their own people into Israel and give them a home, and it wasn't even their fault that those Jews became refugees. The Arabs CREATED their refugee problem and want to lay it someone else's doorstep. The world is always having to clean up after them. They need to take rsponsibility for their own mess.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Definition of repatriate:

re

[apothanein kerdos]

No, some of these Arabs willingly up and left Israel yet the Arab nations turned them back. It's the Arab nations that created the problem, not Israel. You seem to forget the many Arabs that are citizens of Israel.

[amor]

No, some of these Arabs willingly up and left Israel yet the Arab nations turned them back. It's the Arab nations that created the problem, not Israel. You seem to forget the many Arabs that are citizens of Israel.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

No I mentioned them in my post they make up 20% of the population. Which is why committed Zionists would be unhappy about boosting that to nearer 50% by giving full citizenship to all the other Palestinians living under Israeli control.

[apothanein kerdos]

Well yeah, the orthodox would have a problem with it, but who cares? THey're a minority. Regardless, it's a hypothetical. To be a citizen one must announce loyalty to Israel...this is something most Palestinians will not do because it would put them "under" a Jew.

[Guest shiloh357]

Why should Israel have to give up land it won from Jordan and Egypt when it was invaded by them?

Stop being a sore loser Amor. You guys lost, Israel won, it rightfully belongs to them now.

And yes, she did meet with Michael Moore. She was highlighted on his website before the media ever talked to her.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Fine in that case fully annex the West Bank and Gaza, and grant full citizenship rights,including the right to vote to all those who live there. Do you see that as a solution? If you don't, what future do you see for those living in the territories that Israel "won"?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

They don't deserve Israeli citizenship. It was not Israel's fault that the Palestinians are in the West Bank and Gaza. It is the Arab countries that created refugee crisis. They should repatriate their bretheren in Arab lands. It is the least they can do for making them refugees in the first place. That would be the ideal solution. But I guess expecting them to care about their own is asking a too much of them.

The Arabs kicked some 600,000 Jews out of Arab countries in 1948. The Jews had the moral fortitude to take their own people into Israel and give them a home, and it wasn't even their fault that those Jews became refugees. The Arabs CREATED their refugee problem and want to lay it someone else's doorstep. The world is always having to clean up after them. They need to take rsponsibility for their own mess.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Definition of repatriate:

re

[amor]

Why should Israel have to give up land it won from Jordan and Egypt when it was invaded by them?

Stop being a sore loser Amor. You guys lost, Israel won, it rightfully belongs to them now.

And yes, she did meet with Michael Moore. She was highlighted on his website before the media ever talked to her.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Fine in that case fully annex the West Bank and Gaza, and grant full citizenship rights,including the right to vote to all those who live there. Do you see that as a solution? If you don't, what future do you see for those living in the territories that Israel "won"?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

They don't deserve Israeli citizenship. It was not Israel's fault that the Palestinians are in the West Bank and Gaza. It is the Arab countries that created refugee crisis. They should repatriate their bretheren in Arab lands. It is the least they can do for making them refugees in the first place. That would be the ideal solution. But I guess expecting them to care about their own is asking a too much of them.

The Arabs kicked some 600,000 Jews out of Arab countries in 1948. The Jews had the moral fortitude to take their own people into Israel and give them a home, and it wasn't even their fault that those Jews became refugees. The Arabs CREATED their refugee problem and want to lay it someone else's doorstep. The world is always having to clean up after them. They need to take rsponsibility for their own mess.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Definition of repatriate:

re

[Guest shiloh357]

Why should Israel have to give up land it won from Jordan and Egypt when it was invaded by them?

Stop being a sore loser Amor. You guys lost, Israel won, it rightfully belongs to them now.

And yes, she did meet with Michael Moore. She was highlighted on his website before the media ever talked to her.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Fine in that case fully annex the West Bank and Gaza, and grant full citizenship rights,including the right to vote to all those who live there. Do you see that as a solution? If you don't, what future do you see for those living in the territories that Israel "won"?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

They don't deserve Israeli citizenship. It was not Israel's fault that the Palestinians are in the West Bank and Gaza. It is the Arab countries that created refugee crisis. They should repatriate their bretheren in Arab lands. It is the least they can do for making them refugees in the first place. That would be the ideal solution. But I guess expecting them to care about their own is asking a too much of them.

The Arabs kicked some 600,000 Jews out of Arab countries in 1948. The Jews had the moral fortitude to take their own people into Israel and give them a home, and it wasn't even their fault that those Jews became refugees. The Arabs CREATED their refugee problem and want to lay it someone else's doorstep. The world is always having to clean up after them. They need to take rsponsibility for their own mess.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Definition of repatriate:

re