Submission

[gdemoss]

On the topic of Eve saying they must not touch it ir they will die. 

The burden of proof is on the one who lays the claim.  On what authority do you claim God did not tell them not to touch it?  I see no reason not to believe Eve's testimony.  Convince me otherwise please.  Thank you.

Do you think God left out part of His command when given to Adam?

Eve wasn't even created when God gave that command.

So either God didn't say it, or God kept part of it from Adam.

Which do you think is more likely?

 

 

You present options that are reasoned out of yourself.  Imaginative speculation leads to deception.  Please prove to me that God did not tell Eve that ahe would die if she touched the fruit.  Or is this just something you imagine out of your own heart?

[thereselittleflower]

On the topic of Eve saying they must not touch it ir they will die. 

The burden of proof is on the one who lays the claim.  On what authority do you claim God did not tell them not to touch it?  I see no reason not to believe Eve's testimony.  Convince me otherwise please.  Thank you.

Do you think God left out part of His command when given to Adam?

Eve wasn't even created when God gave that command.

So either God didn't say it, or God kept part of it from Adam.

Which do you think is more likely?

 

 

You present options that are reasoned out of yourself.  Imaginative speculation leads to deception.  Please prove to me that God did not tell Eve that ahe would die if she touched the fruit.  Or is this just something you imagine out of your own heart?

I believe you are in error in your assessment.

There is no evidence God ever said such a thing.

Please prove to me He did.

 

 

Edited October 3, 2015 by thereselittleflower

[gdemoss]

On the topic of Eve saying they must not touch it ir they will die. 

The burden of proof is on the one who lays the claim.  On what authority do you claim God did not tell them not to touch it?  I see no reason not to believe Eve's testimony.  Convince me otherwise please.  Thank you.

Do you think God left out part of His command when given to Adam?

Eve wasn't even created when God gave that command.

So either God didn't say it, or God kept part of it from Adam.

Which do you think is more likely?

 

 

You present options that are reasoned out of yourself.  Imaginative speculation leads to deception.  Please prove to me that God did not tell Eve that ahe would die if she touched the fruit.  Or is this just something you imagine out of your own heart?

I believe you are in error in your assessment.

There is no evidence God ever said such a thing.

Please prove to me He did.

 

 

Correct the burden of proof is on me for my claim!  Thank you.  I call Eve as witness to testify from Genesis 3 where she testifies that God said so.  

Your rebuttle?

 

[thereselittleflower]

On the topic of Eve saying they must not touch it ir they will die. 

The burden of proof is on the one who lays the claim.  On what authority do you claim God did not tell them not to touch it?  I see no reason not to believe Eve's testimony.  Convince me otherwise please.  Thank you.

Do you think God left out part of His command when given to Adam?

Eve wasn't even created when God gave that command.

So either God didn't say it, or God kept part of it from Adam.

Which do you think is more likely?

 

 

You present options that are reasoned out of yourself.  Imaginative speculation leads to deception.  Please prove to me that God did not tell Eve that ahe would die if she touched the fruit.  Or is this just something you imagine out of your own heart?

I believe you are in error in your assessment.

There is no evidence God ever said such a thing.

Please prove to me He did.

 

 

Correct the burden of proof is on me for my claim!  Thank you.  I call Eve as witness to testify from Genesis 3 where she testifies that God said so.  

Your rebuttle?

 

Eve is not a witness.

Eve was not there when God gave the command to Adam.

There is no evidence that God told Eve anything about the tree Himself.

So where is your evidence that God told Eve that and Eve is not actually mistaken?

 

[thereselittleflower]

gdemoss, you see when you have a witness on the stand and their testimony is in question, their testimony does not prove their testimony.  That would be engaging in the logical fallacy of circular argumentation.

 

[gdemoss]

On the topic of Eve saying they must not touch it ir they will die. 

The burden of proof is on the one who lays the claim.  On what authority do you claim God did not tell them not to touch it?  I see no reason not to believe Eve's testimony.  Convince me otherwise please.  Thank you.

Do you think God left out part of His command when given to Adam?

Eve wasn't even created when God gave that command.

So either God didn't say it, or God kept part of it from Adam.

Which do you think is more likely?

 

 

You present options that are reasoned out of yourself.  Imaginative speculation leads to deception.  Please prove to me that God did not tell Eve that ahe would die if she touched the fruit.  Or is this just something you imagine out of your own heart?

I believe you are in error in your assessment.

There is no evidence God ever said such a thing.

Please prove to me He did.

 

 

Correct the burden of proof is on me for my claim!  Thank you.  I call Eve as witness to testify from Genesis 3 where she testifies that God said so.  

Your rebuttle?

 

Eve is not a witness.

Eve was not there when God gave the command to Adam.

There is no evidence that God told Eve anything about the tree Himself.

So where is your evidence that God told Eve that and Eve is not actually mistaken?

 

Once again you are claiming Eve is mistaken.  That you aomehow know Hod did not tell Eve what she said he did.  The burden of proof is on you. I simply believe that it is as Eve said it was, that God told her.

[gdemoss]

Sorry for typos lol

[thereselittleflower]

 

On the topic of Eve saying they must not touch it ir they will die. 

The burden of proof is on the one who lays the claim.  On what authority do you claim God did not tell them not to touch it?  I see no reason not to believe Eve's testimony.  Convince me otherwise please.  Thank you.

Do you think God left out part of His command when given to Adam?

Eve wasn't even created when God gave that command.

So either God didn't say it, or God kept part of it from Adam.

Which do you think is more likely?

 

 

You present options that are reasoned out of yourself.  Imaginative speculation leads to deception.  Please prove to me that God did not tell Eve that ahe would die if she touched the fruit.  Or is this just something you imagine out of your own heart?

I believe you are in error in your assessment.

There is no evidence God ever said such a thing.

Please prove to me He did.

 

 

Correct the burden of proof is on me for my claim!  Thank you.  I call Eve as witness to testify from Genesis 3 where she testifies that God said so.  

Your rebuttle?

 

Eve is not a witness.

Eve was not there when God gave the command to Adam.

There is no evidence that God told Eve anything about the tree Himself.

So where is your evidence that God told Eve that and Eve is not actually mistaken?

 

Once again you are claiming Eve is mistaken.  That you aomehow know Hod did not tell Eve what she said he did.  The burden of proof is on you. I simply believe that it is as Eve said it was, that God told her.

 

Please see my last post.

Also, what you propose is that God failed to tell Adam the full command, for that is where the logic you're using takes us.

Did God fail to tell Adam the full command?

[hmbld]

If God walk in the garden and talked with Adam and eve, then he could have told her directly not  to touch it. Regardless that is all speculation, however that does not change the fact that Eve knew not to eat it

[thereselittleflower]

If God walk in the garden and talked with Adam and eve, then he could have told her directly not  to touch it. Regardless that is all speculation, however that does not change the fact that Eve knew not to eat it

So God failed to disclose that piece of information from Adam when He gave the command about the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil?