Is Melania's marriage valid?

[hmbld]

3 hours ago, OldSchool2 said:

"Is Melania’s marriage valid in the eyes of her church?" is the title of the article you obviously didn't read.

 

Answer: It does not matter.  

[OldSchool2]

7 hours ago, hmbld said:

Answer: It does not matter.  

If you're Roman Catholic -- and Melania is RC -- it does matter because an invalid marriage means you can be denied church sacraments, especially Holy Communion.

"... Unless you eat my body and drink my blood, there is no life in you " (John 6:53).

[OldSchool2]

10 hours ago, The_Patriot2017 said:

not at all, but I think were both smart enough to know its an indirect attack at Trump, by going after his family....

But Pope Francis didn't go after his family, despite the fact that Melania married a twice-divorced Protestant with a step-daughter who left Christianity to marry Trump's Jewish son-in-law.

Why can't you see that?

[other one]

27 minutes ago, OldSchool2 said:

If you're Roman Catholic -- and Melania is RC -- it does matter because an invalid marriage means you can be denied church sacraments, especially Holy Communion.

"... Unless you eat my body and drink my blood, there is no life in you " (John 6:53).

Are you saying that none of us who are not Catholics and can not receive the Eucharist are dead and hopelessly lost?

[hmbld]

1 hour ago, OldSchool2 said:

If you're Roman Catholic -- and Melania is RC -- it does matter because an invalid marriage means you can be denied church sacraments, especially Holy Communion.

"... Unless you eat my body and drink my blood, there is no life in you " (John 6:53).

Like I said, it does not matter.  No one can receive life from any church sacraments.  

[The_Patriot21]

1 hour ago, OldSchool2 said:

But Pope Francis didn't go after his family, despite the fact that Melania married a twice-divorced Protestant with a step-daughter who left Christianity to marry Trump's Jewish son-in-law.

Why can't you see that?

Because I read the article, and going after the validity of her and Trumps marriage is very much an attack, nothing more then a cheap shot.

[PlanetChee]

56 minutes ago, The_Patriot2017 said:

Because I read the article, and going after the validity of her and Trumps marriage is very much an attack, nothing more then a cheap shot.

That well describes the OP that started this whole thing. The lows that are arrived at to smear the leader God tells us we're to respect is concerning.

[OldSchool2]

4 hours ago, The_Patriot2017 said:

Because I read the article, and going after the validity of her and Trumps marriage is very much an attack....

... by a conservative Catholic Church led by the liberal Pope Francis? 

The previous pope -- the conservative Benedict XVI -- wouldn't have let the Trump's into the Vatican. But Francis is a very different pope.

And Trump isn't Roman Catholic; he's Presbyterian.

[The_Patriot21]

Just now, OldSchool2 said:

... by a conservative Catholic Church led by the liberal Pope Francis? 

The previous pope -- the conservative Benedict XVI -- wouldn't have let the Trump's into the Vatican. But Francis is a very different pope.

And Trump isn't Roman Catholic; he's Presbyterian.

And again, so what? The only way I can see why one would care is if it was an attack against trump. Though in reality, it sounds like your problem should be with the RCC.

[OldSchool2]

11 hours ago, other one said:

Are you saying that none of us who are not Catholics and can not receive the Eucharist are dead and hopelessly lost?

"If you're Roman Catholic -- and Melania is RC -- it does matter because an invalid marriage means you can be denied church sacraments, especially Holy Communion...."

What part of "If you're Roman Catholic" didn't you understand?

Then again, high church liturgical Lutheran, Episcopal as well Presbyterian denominations do celebrate communion in one form or another.

Edited June 4, 2017 by OldSchool2
added after thought