Are there two creation stories?

[jmldn2]

There is the creation account in Genesis 1 and then Genesis 2 goes on about creation again.  To me there is only one creation story in Genesis 1 with Genesis 2 being a more succinct telling. 

[Esther4:14]

yes, I agree with you.  I even thought it was hilarious when I found out this was the subject of theological debate.  

[missmuffet]

Question: "Why are there two different Creation accounts in Genesis chapters 1-2?"

Answer: Genesis 1:1 says, “In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth.” Later, in Genesis 2:4, it seems that a second, different story of creation begins. The idea of two differing creation accounts is a common misinterpretation of these two passages which, in fact, describe the same creation event. They do not disagree as to the order in which things were created and do not contradict one another. Genesis 1 describes the “six days of creation” (and a seventh day of rest), Genesis 2 covers only one day of that creation week—the sixth day—and there is no contradiction.

In Genesis 2, the author steps back in the temporal sequence to the sixth day, when God made man. In the first chapter, the author of Genesis presents the creation of man on the sixth day as the culmination or high point of creation. Then, in the second chapter, the author gives greater detail regarding the creation of man.

There are two primary claims of contradictions between Genesis chapters 1-2. The first is in regard to plant life.Genesis 1:11 records God creating vegetation on the third day. Genesis 2:5 states that prior to the creation of man “no shrub of the field had yet appeared on the earth and no plant of the field had yet sprung up, for the LORD God had not sent rain on the earth and there was no man to work the ground.” So, which is it? Did God create vegetation on the third day before He created man (Genesis 1), or after He created man (Genesis 2)? The Hebrew words for “vegetation” are different in the two passages. Genesis 1:11 uses a term that refers to vegetation in general. Genesis 2:5 uses a more specific term that refers to vegetation that requires agriculture, i.e., a person to tend it, a gardener. The passages do not contradict. Genesis 1:11 speaks of God creating vegetation, and Genesis 2:5 speaks of God not causing “farmable” vegetation to grow until after He created man.

The second claimed contradiction is in regard to animal life. Genesis 1:24-25 records God creating animal life on the sixth day, before He created man. Genesis 2:19, in some translations, seems to record God creating the animals after He had created man. However, a good and plausible translation of Genesis 2:19-20 reads, “Now the LORD God had formed out of the ground all the beasts of the field and all the birds of the air. He brought them to the man to see what he would name them, and whatever the man called each living creature, that was its name. So the man gave names to all the livestock, the birds of the air and all the beasts of the field.” The text does not say that God created man, then created the animals, and then brought the animals to the man. Rather, the text says, “Now the LORD God had [already] created all the animals.” There is no contradiction. On the sixth day, God created the animals, then created man, and then brought the animals to the man, allowing the man to name the animals.

By considering the two creation accounts individually and then reconciling them, we see that God describes the sequence of creation in Genesis 1, then clarifies its most important details, especially of the sixth day, in Genesis 2. There is no contradiction here, merely a common literary device describing an event from the general to the specific.

http://www.gotquestions.org/two-Creation-accounts.html

Edited September 18, 2015 by bopeep1909

[Secret__]

There is the creation account in Genesis 1 and then Genesis 2 goes on about creation again.  To me there is only one creation story in Genesis 1 with Genesis 2 being a more succinct telling. 

There is only one, but there is info I can eventually share that is not so obvious.

[Guest shiloh357]

There is the creation account in Genesis 1 and then Genesis 2 goes on about creation again.  To me there is only one creation story in Genesis 1 with Genesis 2 being a more succinct telling. 

No, those are not two creation accounts.   It is the same account that covers two chapters.  The Bible was not originally written in chapter and verse.  Genesis 1 and 2 are part of one line of thought. 

Genesis chapter two is a summation of chapter one and then a concentrated focus on the sixth day to give more detail about all that happened on that day.

[Ezra]

That people would even imagine that there are two creation stories shows the dumbing down of Bible knowledge.  Genesis 1 provides the overview while Genesis 2 focuses on mankind (since man was created to have dominion over the rest of creation as indicated by the naming of all creatures).

[Guest]

Genesis 1 is GOD's telling of Creation, while Genesis 2 is Adam's telling. They don't contradict each other at all.

[xyluz]

Genesis 1 is GOD's telling of Creation, while Genesis 2 is Adam's telling. They don't contradict each other at all.

really?

How do you know this?

[xyluz]

There is the creation account in Genesis 1 and then Genesis 2 goes on about creation again.  To me there is only one creation story in Genesis 1 with Genesis 2 being a more succinct telling. 

Yes, i agree... but still, a few things i don't understand... i have just learnt to wait till i understand ..

 

[Littlelambseativy]

One creation story interrupted by time.