How do you think, Pilate's wife to asked for Barabbas or Jesus?

[Ogner]

2 hours ago, enoob57 said:

because she saw Jesus as a just man...

"but" or "also"? And Why? 

[Ogner]

42 minutes ago, Openly Curious said:

Pilate was addressing the mob who wanted to crucify Jesus who was not guilty of any crimes he was an innocent man.  It was at this point when Pilate was addressing the mob asking who they wanted to be released to them either Barrabas who was a known criminal or Jesus who was not guilty of any crimes.  That Pilate's wife at that point sent word to him.  Pilate's wife was not the one asking for the release of Barrabas but the angry mob.

Why did she not say to Pilate immediately,  at this point when hief priests and elders of the people delivered Jesus to Pontius? If she wanted no harm for Jesus...

 

[missmuffet]

Pontius Pilate's wife tried to warn her husband. He chose differently.

Matthew 27:19

[enoob57]

33 minutes ago, Ogner said:

"but" or "also"? And Why? 

I already expressed this in my previous posts...

 Mt 1:19
19 Then Joseph her husband, being a just man, and not willing to make her a publick example, was minded to put her away privily.
KJV
Mt 27:19
19 When he was set down on the judgment seat, his wife sent unto him, saying, Have thou nothing to do with that just man: for I have suffered many things this day in a dream because of him.
KJV
Mk 6:20
20 For Herod feared John, knowing that he was a just man and an holy, and observed him; and when he heard him, he did many things, and heard him gladly.
KJV
Ac 10:22
22 And they said, Cornelius the centurion, a just man, and one that feareth God, and of good report among all the nation of the Jews, was warned from God by an holy angel to send for thee into his house, and to hear words of thee.
KJV
This is what Pilot's wife meant about Jesus saying " Have thou nothing to do with that just man:"
Now back to the question I asked you do you wish to condemn just men? So the answer is she did
not wish to condemn Jesus... Her asking for Barabbas was condemning Jesus to the cross... that is
why the 'but' is there the Pharisees did wish to condemn Jesus to the cross...
Love, Steven

She nor anyone else would want a just man to suffer death on a cross verses the Pharisee who did!

 

[Ezra]

7 hours ago, Ogner said:

How can we prove that Pilate's wife to asked for Jesus? 

She called Jesus a righteous (just = righteous) man. She must have been fully aware of the ministry of Christ, plus she had a dream that clearly showed her that Pilate was not to condemn Christ to death (or that there would be serious consequences for Pilate and his wife).

[Ogner]

1 hour ago, bopeep1909 said:

Pontius Pilate's wife tried to warn her husband. He chose differently.

Matthew 27:19

 John 19:12, "And from thenceforth Pilate sought to release him: "

Pilate chose to release Jesus before that his wife sent unto him. 
And the Jews understood this.That's why they said, "but the Jews cried out, saying, If thou let this man go, thou art not Caesar's friend: whosoever maketh himself a king speaketh against Caesar."

Do you think, Pilate's wife after that still doesn't get it?

Or do you say that she chose to destroy Jesus but Pilate chose differently?

Edited June 6, 2016 by Ogner

[Ogner]

16 minutes ago, Ezra said:

She called Jesus a righteous (just = righteous) man. She must have been fully aware of the ministry of Christ, plus she had a dream that clearly showed her that Pilate was not to condemn Christ to death (or that there would be serious consequences for Pilate and his wife).

This is speculation and stereotypes. 

How do you know she called Jesus a righteous? She might mean Barabbas.

The Jews chose Barabbas and she might mean Barabbas.

The choice between Jesus or Barabbas is not choice between righteous or sinner.

 it's a question: "Who do you think is a righteous or a sinner, Jesus or Barabbas?"

[Openly Curious]

1 hour ago, Ogner said:

Why did she not say to Pilate immediately,  at this point when hief priests and elders of the people delivered Jesus to Pontius? If she wanted no harm for Jesus...

 

It was revealed to Pilate's wife the night before in a dream that Jesus was a innocent man he was not guilty of any wrong doing that he was being accused of.  Pilate's wife according to the scripture suffered in her sleep as that truth was being revealed to her.  The next morning when Pilate's wife woke up she sent word to her husband Pilate what had been revealed to her in a dream concerning Jesus being an innocent man.  You can read in all four accounts found in the gospels in Matthew 27:1-26; Mark 15:1-15; Luke 22:66-23:1-25 & John 18:28 - 19:1-16 which I encouraged you to read.  

Pilate conclusion was that Jesus was an innocent man after questioning and talking with Jesus himself.  Pilate told the angry crowd that he found no fault with him as Pilate washed his hands so that he wouldn't be guilty of having the blood of an innocent man on his hands.  The angry mob said back to Pilate to let Jesus's blood be on their own hands and on the hands of their children.

It was actually revealed or made known to Pilate's wife that Jesus was not guilty of any wrong doing first because of her dream.  The next morning after coming to his own conclusions having talked with Jesus it was made known to Pilate himself Jesus was not guilty of any wrong doing for he was a just man having no faults.

 

[Ogner]

27 minutes ago, Openly Curious said:

It was revealed to Pilate's wife the night before in a dream that Jesus was a innocent man he was not guilty of any wrong doing that he was being accused of.  Pilate's wife according to the scripture suffered in her sleep as that truth was being revealed to her.  The next morning when Pilate's wife woke up she sent word to her husband Pilate what had been revealed to her in a dream concerning Jesus being an innocent man.  You can read in all four accounts found in the gospels in Matthew 27:1-26; Mark 15:1-15; Luke 22:66-23:1-25 & John 18:28 - 19:1-16 which I encouraged you to read.  

Pilate conclusion was that Jesus was an innocent man after questioning and talking with Jesus himself.  Pilate told the angry crowd that he found no fault with him as Pilate washed his hands so that he wouldn't be guilty of having the blood of an innocent man on his hands.  The angry mob said back to Pilate to let Jesus's blood be on their own hands and on the hands of their children.

It was actually revealed or made known to Pilate's wife that Jesus was not guilty of any wrong doing first because of her dream.  The next morning after coming to his own conclusions having talked with Jesus it was made known to Pilate himself Jesus was not guilty of any wrong doing for he was a just man having no faults.

 

Your interpretation is based upon translation from Greek into English.

If the Greek word "δὲ" is translated as "also". That means Pilate's wife to asked for Barabbas.

You cannot prove what your translation is correct to your interpretation of your translation. 

 

Edited June 6, 2016 by Ogner

[other one]

so you are saying that Pilot's wife asked him to kill an innocent man........   really?

 

I would think you might want to take a course in Greek before trying to change the Bible using  strongs references.